"It is not the critic who counts: not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood, who strives valiantly, who errs and comes up short again and again, because there is no effort without error or shortcoming, but who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions, who spends himself for a worthy cause; who, at the best, knows, in the end, the triumph of high achievement, and who, at the worst, if he fails, at least he fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who knew neither victory nor defeat." Theodore Roosevelt

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Response to "Winter Chill" by Lauren Barkley

Lauren’s story “Winter Chill” tells the story of a man who is annoyed by his job and his wife. He works as a funeral home curator and embalms the bodies that come into the home. His funeral home is the only one in the area and it is currently winter which means business is booming. I thought that the man being mauled by a mountain lion and it seeming so normal was a little much. Even in the snowy hills of the mountains it is not an every day occurrence that someone dies by means of mountain lion. Just a minor detail, I digress.

The story picks up heat when Mr. Smart reads a text on Mrs. Smart’s phone that leads him to believe she is cheating. I believe that this is a reasonable assumption for Mr. Smart to make if there has been a past that has led him to believe this. The story explains how she flirts with the local men at times but actually taking the flirting past the front yard and on to a secret life kept from her husband is a huge leap. I would like to see more tension and build up of Mr. Smart’s distrust of his wife.

I think the best part of the story is when Mrs. Smart gets the phone call in the end. We as readers have been expecting this to happen the whole time and I think you handled the situation well. However, this feels like the climax of your story. If the climax is Mr. Smart finding that text message then make it a more powerful scene with more anticipation and build to that moment. The moment I anticipated from the very beginning was the moment he got in an accident driving the hearse on the icy roads. I don’t think the story can end with that phone call, if it does the opportunity for either of the characters to change or grow is monumentally truncated and I believe it takes away from the purpose of your story and makes it read like a typical thriller with a cliff hanger tale. I think your setting is great, the story has so much potential and I look forward to seeing what it will become!

Monday, February 20, 2012

Response to "Holes full of dirt" by Ethan Hightower

This story is a classic tale of younger boy falling for the older girl and going to extremes to impress her, which end up getting him in trouble. To be more specific the story tells the tale of a fifteen-year-old boy (Jeremy) who gets taken home from school by Ashlyn who is seventeen and when she comments on how dangerous his dirt road has become he decides to fix it in an attempt to impress and woo her. While he is working he thinks that she will be impressed by his maturity and work ethic. Because he is not actually mature and is not doing it to develop a work ethic he ends up getting into trouble when his Dad’s truck gets stuck in the mud on the ditch. Jeremy’s dad, like most parents, can realize that he is extremely distraught by the entire situation and only offers words of encouragement instead of anger.

I thought this was a very believable parental action, but to make it 100% believable I think the Dad needs to show more interest on why his son took the sudden incentive to take on the task of fixing the entire road. This is not exactly normal for a fifteen-year-old boy unless there is an ulterior motive and I would like to see the Dad know this and take interest and maybe dispense some fatherly advice on his puppy love-sick son.

I would work on the conversation between Jeremy and his friend Denver because their language and even the entire motive of their conversation seems a little deep for fifteen year olds. Yes, I do believe Denver can call him out on doing the work and going to the baseball game because he knows that Ashlyn will be there, but having him accuse Jeremy of doing it for wanting a work ethic and having Jeremy claiming to be doing it because of a desire to grow his work ethic both seem a tad austere for boys that are fifteen. When I was a fifteen year old I didn’t talk like that and I don’t think any other fifteen year old boys did either. If you work on making their conversation more believable I believe it will help your story. I also do not fully see how Jeremy has changed over the course of the story so maybe work on solidifying that as well. I enjoyed reading your work and look forward to discussing it in depth tomorrow!

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Response to "The last bit of home-made sugar" by Nate

Nate’s story “The last bit of home-made sugar” is a very captivating and heart-breaking tale. The story is portrayed from the point of view of a boy, maybe in his teens, and his experiences on his family’s little ridge top community. You can feel the whispers of Appalachian trails and stories throughout the tale and I absolutely love that, those mountains have made me who I am and I think Nate captures a part of their character very well through the story of the family who lives on the ridge. I know this is a Fiction writing class, but I can’t help but feel as if this story is semi-autobiographical. I can’t exactly place why I believe this, but something in the language convinces me so. The story follows the day of the protagonist as he walks through the woods on his families land and reminisces on the family’s old days. The boy visits his grandfather and in his cabin and then goes to dinner, at the dinner he is thinking about how all his family is aging and how they all complain. I love how without saying it directly you can feel the apprehension of the main character as he feels as if he is just waiting for the first family member to die. Not in a sadistic kind of way but rather a foreboding feeling of apprehension. Then the phone rings and they find out that, “Jonsey just had a heart attack.” This is the climax of the story and I believe the part where the protagonist is thrown from being a child to an adult. It is a strange and painful transition but when he has to break in a window, do CPR, and then ends up getting left in the dark as the truck carrying his first dying relative speeds up the icy drive and out of his sight.

The imagery is beautiful as is the setting, but I would like to see a bigger build up of apprehension about his aging relatives. Maybe the dead animal he sees on his hike could really start him thinking about it and make him scared? I think the story has an Appalachian charm to it, but I would like more conflict and buildup to the climax. Great work Nate! Your writing always makes me miss home and the beautiful mountain trails that I grew up on. Lets go on a hike soon!