"It is not the critic who counts: not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood, who strives valiantly, who errs and comes up short again and again, because there is no effort without error or shortcoming, but who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions, who spends himself for a worthy cause; who, at the best, knows, in the end, the triumph of high achievement, and who, at the worst, if he fails, at least he fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who knew neither victory nor defeat." Theodore Roosevelt

Monday, February 13, 2012

Response to "Off" by Aimee Bender

Aimee Bender’s short story “Off” was a fun read. From the very beginning you enter the mind of a character with a goal: to kiss three flavors of men, blonde, redhead, and black hair. Never for a second is this strange goal even questioned, rather it is accepted and thus the story begins.

I thought it was interesting how we learned about the main character. I still can’t decide if I dislike her a see her as a godless woman or rather pity her and see her as no more than a woman desperate for connection and attention. But I know she is one of the two from her goal and the way she justifies actions such as drunkenly stealing all the coats in an attempt to seem cute and drunk to entice her third man, the black haired fellow.

The story itself was not exactly enticing or dramatic, rather it was the drunken inner thoughts of a girl at a party. Almost too typical to be interesting, but this girl is so messed up I couldn’t stop reading. She is so desperate to meet her goal that she schemes ways to make herself attractive for the different guys she seduces. Its captivating. I couldn’t help but read on to try and see what crazy antic she would try and pull next.

My only and biggest critique for this story is the fact that it doesn't really captivate me. I read on because I was assigned the story and because I was mildly interest in what the character was going to do next, but the plot never peaked for me and I felt like I was just being dragged along on some drunken desperate party girls journey the entire story. That's not how I want my setories to read. There was not enough tension or action for me.

What I want to be able to pull from this story into my own writing is Bender’s ability to make a character instantly seem real and instantly have a connection with the reader. I may not respect or value the character but I do not doubt her motives.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Response to "Love of My Life" by T.C. Boyle

T. C. Boyle’s “Love of My Life” is not at all what I was expecting to read when I first read the title. The title disgusted me when I first saw it because I was expected a sloppy soppy love story about star-crossed teens finding true love. I guess in a way I was right but in more ways I believe I was wrong. The piece was captivating but there are two parts that I can’t get out of my head. The first was the graphic threat that China made to crawl into the woods and bleed to death instead of going to a hospital. That was brilliant. It equated her to an animal and made her fear absolutely animalistic. Boyle’s is genius. The second scene I could not get out of my mind was when Jeremy threw the baby into the dumpster. It was so abrupt and startling and I absolutely did not see it coming. When he describes the noise the baby made as it hit the dumpster my stomach turned. I personally have not heard such a noise and I’m pretty sure most readers of the story are in the same boat as me, however I have thrown trash into dumpsters and heard the noise it makes many a times. I think that’s why it was so powerful. Boyle took something relatable and turned it into something morose and powerful. I also think this story is relevant because of the age of the characters, being close to our age. Boyle’s story was wonderful to read.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Response to "New Coach" by Lauren Sides

This story is about Kaylee coming to terms with the fact that her cheerleading coach Alex is a crazy control freak who doesn’t actually care about the individuals on the team more than he does winning. Because of this Kaylee injures herself in practice one day (tears her ACL). But because she wants to remain a part of the team so badly she experiments with bulimia and abuses her body to stay in shape for Alex until he pushes her to throw a tumbling pass that she knows would hurt her again. She decides in the end not to throw the pass even though it means giving up all she has worked towards for many years and a possible future as a FSU cheerleader.

I liked how the dialogue was natural. Alex is a complete lunatic and we clearly understand that through his demanding speeches and verbal abuse of the cheerleaders. The story captures really well how much the girls made cheering into an idol because they made Alex’s acceptance into an idol. This is something that all athletes are tempted to do, you want your coaches approval. It’s something we all do, we all want approval and have to come to the point where we realize there is more than pleasing people in this life. I liked the structure of the story as well. How it began in the middle then backtracked and then caught back up and led you to the end was very entertaining. It kept it from becoming boring.

I would have liked to have seen more poetic language. The story is definite but there is such opportunity to express the pain of the injury, the fury at Alex, the fear of the parents, the desperation of bulimia, and the loss of a dream in a more poetic way. More figurative language please! I would also like more of a setting. We know the girl is in high school but tell us more about her as an individual. I also felt like I have heard this sports injury story before, maybe add an unexpected twist to aid your building of tension? I enjoyed reading your work and look forward to more!